Advantages and Disadvantages of Different Curriculum Designs

By

Question: With examples analyse  the advantages  and  weakness  of each of curriculum  design (a) Subject centered  curriculum  design (b) Learner  centered  curriculum  design  (c) problem  centered curriculum design.

Answer

Curriculum is a standards-based sequence of planned experiences where students practice and achieve proficiency in content and applied learning skills. Curriculum is the central guide for all educators as to what is essential for teaching and learning, so that every student has access to rigorous academic experiences.

Subject-centered curriculum design revolves around a particular subject matter or discipline. For example, a subject-centered curriculum may focus on math or biology. This type of curriculum design tends to focus on the subject rather than the individual.

Jackson, Stratford, Krajcik, & Soloway, 2000; Quintana et al., 2000 further explained that learner-centered design "considers learning while doing; it supports learners in the ways of using the software and throughout the use of it. It also indicates how and why to do the learning tasks. Moreover, these authors have defined learner-centered design as “the new challenge for human-computer interaction, with the goal of providing support for both learning a task and doing it.”

Problem centered curriculum design a curriculum design that also uses a student approach but that instructs students to look at a problem or situation and figure out a way to solve it. Teachers expect students to use their real-life experiences to determine an answer.

Subject centered curriculum design have the following advantages:

Almost all textbooks and support materials present on the educational market are organized on subject-by-subject format. Writers write their lessons based on the relevant subject. When they write books, they follow the guidelines in the syllabus.

Another advantage of Subject centered curriculum is Curriculum planning is easier and simpler in the subject centered curriculum design. Imagine the period of planning, developing and implementing the curriculum. Also imagine what goes in your first staff meeting when every teacher is to be allocated his/her teaching load for the year and how this should be plotted on the daily school time-table. It is simply and easily achieved at a short time.

Also, Subject centered curriculum design have the following disadvantages:

Subject-centered curriculum prevents students from understanding the wider context of what they’re learning. In the traditional method of learning, students learn math in one period, reading in another, science in another and social studies in yet another, separate class. Every subject is taught as though it exists in and of itself without regard for how one subject impacts another subject. Teachers provide math worksheets, which the students work to complete. Math problems are devoid of real-world applications. The same goes for other subjects studied. Students may learn the history of Tanzania but not how history both past and current impacts this segment of the Tanzanians in relation to their culture, African culture and the world at large.

Passive Learning, in the traditional or subject-centered curriculum, students are discouraged from entertaining a different point of view than what textbook or teacher presents. The subject matter has already been chosen by experts in the different subjects, by school boards and by teachers and deemed of value for students to learn. The subject matter is of critical importance, while students become little more than receptacles to be filled, rather than thinking, rational individuals who need to be part of the learning process. The subject-centered curriculum fosters not excitement about learning and knowledge, but passivity.

On the other hand, Learner centered curriculum design have the following advantages:

Improves participation. The first step towards the success of any Learning program is participation. A learner centered approach addresses all the essential needs of learners, ensuring learners get a personalized and convenient learning experience. For example, if a certain learner group prefers games and exercises, the courses should be made more interactive. Similarly, if learners are more likely to access the course content on tablets or mobiles, the courses should be designed to support this need. Due to the minute attention paid to learner’s needs, learner centered courses ensure greater participation in learning.

Transitions students from passive to active learners. Empowered students can explore what genuinely interests them and what they are passionate about. They can take ownership of their work and their ideas. It encourages creativity, originality, and responsibility in what they are taking away from their learning experience.

The following are disadvantages of Learner centered curriculum design:

An approach to learning with not as much structure or discipline as a traditional method, causing students to feel overwhelmed and maybe not pull as much from learning as they normally would.

Another disadvantage to learner-centered instruction would be too much independence. The student is free to do all the work. If the teacher is not careful, mistakes made can be unseen.

In either case, the following are advantages of problem centered curriculum design:

Development of Long-Term Knowledge Retention, students who participate in problem-based learning activities can improve their abilities to retain and recall information, according to a literature review of studies about the pedagogy. The literature review states “elaboration of knowledge at the time of learning” -- by sharing facts and ideas through discussion and answering questions -- “enhances subsequent retrieval.” This form of elaborating reinforces understanding of subject matter, making it easier to remember. Small-group discussion can be especially beneficial -- ideally, each student will get chances to participate. But regardless of group size, problem-based learning promotes long-term knowledge retention by encouraging students to discuss -- and answer questions about -- new concepts as they’re learning them.

Development of Transferable Skills, Problem-based learning can help students develop skills they can transfer to real-world scenarios, according to a 2015 book that outlines theories and characteristics of the pedagogy. The tangible contexts and consequences presented in a problem-based learning activity “allow learning to become more profound and durable.” As you present lessons through these real-life scenarios, students should be able to apply learnings if they eventually face similar issues.

Also, the following are disadvantages of problem based learning:

Potentially Poorer Performance on Tests, Devoting too much time to problem-based learning can cause issues when students take standardized tests, as they may not have the breadth of knowledge needed to achieve high scores. Whereas problem-based learners develop skills related to collaboration and justifying their reasoning, many tests reward fact-based learning with multiple choice and short answer questions. Despite offering many advantages, you could spot this problem develop if you run problem-based learning activities too regularly.

Time-Consuming Assessment, if you choose to give marks, assessing a student’s performance throughout a problem-based learning exercise demands constant monitoring and note-taking. You must take factors into account such as: Completed tasks, The quality of those tasks, The group’s overall work and solution, Communication among team members, Anything you outlined on the activity’s rubric, Monitoring these criteria is required for each student, making it time-consuming to give and justify a mark for everyone.

Finally, all of the curriculum design have their advantages and disadvantages. The question might be what is the best curriculum design to be used in our education? The best curriculum design should have the following features: Every aspect of the curriculum should have a clear objective or end goal to achieve. A good curriculum is not rigid-it allows room for flexibility, monitoring and evaluation by administration. It should provide sufficient scope for the cultivation of unique skills, interest, attitudes and appreciations.

References:

Marsh, C & Wills, G (1995). Curriculum; Alternative Approaches, Ongoing Issues; Stoughton.

Posner, G (2004). Analyzing the Curriculum. New York. Mc Grow Hill Publishers.

William E. Dull Jr (1993), New York; Post Modern Perspective on Curriculum.

Njabili A.F (1999); Public Examinations; A tool for Curriculum Evaluation. Mture Educational Publishers.

Ralph W. Tyler; Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instructions.

Popular posts from this blog

Jinsi ya Kuandika CV | Mfano wa CV Wasifu

By
Image
Kitaalamu Zaidi, Tunaweza Kukuandikia Barua ya Maombi ya Kazi na CV Uitwe Katika Usaili na Upate Kazi. Barua Tsh. 5,000/= na CV Tsh. 9,000/=. Gusa Hapa Kuwasiliana Nasi. CV au wasifu ni kitu cha lazima kwa yeyote anayeomba kazi. Watu wengi wanaokosa kazi, tatizo huwa siyo wao, bali tatizo huwa ni CV zao. Kumekuwa na makosa mengi katika uandishi wa CV jambo ambalo limesababisha watafuta kazi wengi kushindwa kuitwa kwenye usaili. Makala hii itakueleza namna sahihi ya kuandika CV, utaitwa katika ‘interview’ nyingi endapo utaandika CV sahihi. Tena nakukumbusha, kila taaluma ina aina yake ya CV, CV ya rubani haifanani na CV ya injinia. Vivyo hivyo, CV ya mpishi haifananani na CV ya Mwalimu. Pia nakukumbusha usome jinsi ya kuandika barua ya maombi ya kazi , kwani CV huenda pamoja na barua ya maombi ya kazi. CV Bora ni Ipi? Ukurasa Mmoja au Kurasa mbili hadi tatu? CV bora ni ile yenye kurasa mbili hadi tatu. Watu wengi wanapojifunza namna ya kuandika CV, wamekuwa wakiona CV zenye ukurasa...
Read More»

Fasihi ni Zao la Jamii | Harusi ya Dogoli na Vuta n’kuvute

By
Image
Swali Kwa mifano dhahiri kutoka katika riwaya ya Harusi ya Dogoli ya Athumani Mauya na Vuta N’kuvute ya Shafi Adam Shafi, jadili dai kuwa, fasihi ni zao la jamii. Jibu Zipo maana nyingi za fasihi zilizotolewa na wataalamu mbalimbali. Ya kwanza ni ile inayosema, Fasihi ni kioo cha maisha. Kwa maana kwamba, mtu anaweza akajitazama, akaona taswira yake na akajirekebisha, (Nkwera, 1970). Kwa ujumla, fasihi ni sanaa inayotumia lugha ili kufikisha ujumbe wake kwa jamii. Fasihi ni zao la jamii, hii ina maana kuwa, kazi zote za fasihi huandikwa kutoka katika jamii. Yaani fasihi huchota mambo fulani yaliyopo katika jamii ndipo ikaandikwa. Mifano dhahiri ya kauli hii, inajadiliwa kupitia riwaya mbili: Vuta N’kuvute yake Shafi Adam Shafi na Harusi ya Dogoli yake Athumani Mauya. Fasihi ni zao la jamii kwani inapata dhamira zake katika jamii. Katika Vuta N’kuvute Mwandishi anajadili dhamira ya mapenzi ameiga mapenzi halisi yaliyo katika jamii yetu na kuyaweka katika kitabu. Tunamuona k...
Read More»

Jinsi ya Kuandika Barua ya Maombi ya Kazi Mwaka 2024

By
Image
Kitaalamu Zaidi, Tunaweza Kukuandikia Barua ya Maombi ya Kazi na CV Uitwe Katika Usaili na Upate Kazi. Barua Tsh. 5,000/= na CV Tsh. 9,000/=. Gusa Hapa Kuwasiliana Nasi. Umewekeza katika elimu yako, una kila sifa ya kupata kazi fulani lakini hupati kazi hiyo, inawezekana kabisa sababu mojawapo inayokufanya usipate kazi unayoitaka ni kutokujua kuandika barua ya maombi ya kazi au unapoandika, unaandika katika namna mbaya inayofanya waajiri wakupuuze. Kwa muda mrefu nimekuwa nikiulizwa na wanafunzi na wasomaji wa mtandao wangu kuhusu jinsi ya kuandika barua ya maombi ya kazi kwa kiswahili, na wengine huuliza kuhusu jinsi ya kuandika barua ya maombi ya kazi kwa kiingereza. Waombaji wengi huuliza kuhusu maombi ya kazi ya udereva, hotelini, kazi za polisi, ualimu, afya utendaji wa kijiji na kazi chungu nzima ambazo haziwezi kutosha hapa zikiandikwa. Kazi zote siku hizi zinahitaji kuandika barua, hata kama unataka kujitolea, lazima utaandika barua! Isivyo bahati ni kuwa, hata mtandaoni ...
Read More»